Rock Salt (Sodium Chloride) vs. Magnesium Chloride Ice Melt
Every winter, property managers and contractors face the same question: What’s the best ice melt for keeping surfaces safe without destroying concrete or harming the environment? Let’s answer this question once and for all.
Today we’ll look at sodium chloride (rock salt) and magnesium chloride: two popular de-icer choices. Both get the job done, but not in the same way. Each has its own strengths, costs, and side effects. In this blog, our team at Ninja De-Icer will explain their differences and how to choose the right product for your climate, surfaces, and budget.
What Is Rock Salt?
If you picture salt trucks spreading granules before a snowstorm, that’s usually rock salt, or sodium chloride (NaCl). It’s mined from underground salt deposits and has been the workhorse of snow and ice removal for decades.
-
How it works: Sodium chloride lowers water’s freezing point, forming a brine that helps loosen ice from pavement.
-
Effective range: Works best above 15°F, but starts losing power below that.
-
Drawbacks: It’s endothermic, meaning it absorbs heat instead of producing it, so melting slows in severe cold. It’s also corrosive to metal and harsh on concrete surfaces and vegetation.
Popular Sodium Chloride Products
-
Halite Rock Salt is a classic de-icing solution, composed primarily of sodium chloride. This white-colored salt is effective in melting ice in temperatures as low as 5°F, making it a reliable choice for combating icy conditions. Halite rock salt has a straightforward composition and efficacy, making it a staple for winter safety in various settings.
-
Royal Blue Halite Rock Salt, mined directly from the earth, is a high-quality ASTM-1 grade sodium chloride treated with an anti-caking agent to prevent clumping and hardening. Its distinctive royal blue color, achieved through dyeing, simplifies application, making it highly visible during spreading. Effective down to 5°F, this rock salt is particularly well-suited for use in parking lot applications, as it offers reliable de-icing performance.
-
Ice Away Rock Salt is crafted for optimal efficiency, featuring specially-sized, chunky halite crystals that maximize ice melting and facilitate easy spreading. Designed to work swiftly and effectively, it's perfect to use on parking lots. This sodium chloride-based product is white and remains effective down to 5°F. We recommend Ice Away Rock Salt bags for a straightforward, effective ice-melting solution.
Rock Salt (Halite) 50 Lbs Bag
Starting at $4.12 (per bag)
At Ninja De-Icer, we recommend using treated rock salt for several reasons: it melts faster, resists clumping with an anti-caking agent, and includes corrosion inhibitors so it is less harsh on equipment and environmental harm.
What Is Magnesium Chloride?
Magnesium chloride (MgCl₂) is also a salt, but it behaves quite differently. It’s exothermic, meaning it releases heat as it dissolves, which speeds up the melting process. This property allows it to perform even in frigid temperatures as low as -20°F.
Magnesium chloride has many benefits:
- Works in colder temperatures than rock salt
- Less corrosive to metal
- Safer for plants, animals, and nearby vegetation
- Rapid burn melts ice quickly and prevents refreezing
Many magnesium chloride products combine sodium chloride with magnesium and a corrosion inhibitor, offering the best of both worlds: fast performance and reduced surface damage.
The following are a few of our top products at Ninja De-Icer.
Top Magnesium Chloride Ice Melts
-
12 Lb Lightning Fast Ice Melter Shaker Jug is an effective de-icing product that combines sodium chloride and magnesium chloride, along with a corrosion inhibitor and a proprietary blend. Its chemical composition offers superior ice melting performance even in temperatures as low as -20°F.
-
Lightning Premium Ice Melter is a high-performance de-icing product that combines the power of sodium chloride, pre-treated with magnesium chloride. A corrosion inhibitor further enhances it to ensure efficient ice melting. With its chemical composition and effective temperature range of -20°F, it is capable of melting ice quickly.
-
Dead Sea MAG 50 Lb Bag is a premium magnesium chloride ice melt naturally harvested from the Dead Sea. Its spherical pellets disperse evenly and bore into snow and ice, creating a melted layer underneath for faster removal. With its pure magnesium chloride composition, it delivers reliable performance in temperatures as low as -13°F while still being safe for concrete, pets, and vegetation.
Lightning Premium Ice Melter 50 Lbs Bag
Starting at $6.30 (per bag)
Dead Sea MAG 50 Lbs Bag
Starting at $19.03 (per bag of pellets)
Starting at $19.78 (per bag of flakes)
Magnesium Chloride vs. Sodium Chloride: A Comprehensive Comparison for De-Icing
When winter hits hard (and let’s face it, it always does), choosing the right de-icing product can make all the difference for commercial properties, municipalities, and business owners responsible for keeping walkways and parking lots safe. Among the most commonly used ice melts, magnesium chloride and sodium chloride (rock salt) stand out as the top contenders.
While both compounds help melt snow and ice, they have different chemical compositions, melting temperatures, environmental impacts, and effectiveness on concrete surfaces.
| Magnesium Chloride vs. Sodium Chloride | ||
|---|---|---|
| Chemical Composition | Magnesium Chloride Ice Melt | Rock Salt (Sodium Chloride) |
| Effectiveness |
Highly effective at lower temperatures, works quickly. |
Effective, but may be slower and less efficient in extreme cold. |
| Temperature | Effective at temperatures as low as -20°F. | Effective down to about 5°F. |
| Cost | Generally more expensive than rock salt. | Less expensive, more widely available. |
| Corrosiveness | Less corrosive than rock salt, safer for metal surfaces and vegetation. | Corrosive, can damage concrete and metal over time. |
| Pet-Friendliness | Generally more pet-friendly, less likely to irritate. | Can be harmful to pets' paws and potentially toxic if ingested in large quantities. |
1. Sodium Chloride vs. Magnesium Chloride Ice Melt: Effectiveness
When it comes to melting snow and ice, magnesium chloride is known for its high efficiency and quick action. Because it’s hygroscopic, meaning it naturally attracts and absorbs moisture from the air, it forms a brine solution almost immediately upon contact.
This accelerates the ice-melting process, helping to break bonds faster and even prevent re-freezing. As a result, magnesium chloride ice melt is highly effective for treating thin ice layers, sidewalks, and parking lots that need rapid, lasting results.
Sodium chloride (rock salt) remains the most common choice for many because of its affordability and availability. However, it’s less effective in extremely low temperatures since it’s endothermic, drawing heat from its surroundings instead of generating it. This limits its performance during severe cold spells, so we recommend it for moderate winter conditions.
More effective: Magnesium chloride
2. Which De-Icer Has a Lower Freezing Temperature?
One of the biggest advantages of magnesium chloride products is their ability to stay active in extremely cold temperatures. For example, this exothermic compound continues to melt ice effectively even at -20°F, making it a reliable choice for regions with harsh winters or overnight temperature drops.
Sodium chloride, meanwhile, works best around 15°F and can still melt ice down to 5°F under the right conditions. However, below that threshold, it struggles to maintain performance and allows ice and snow to refreeze more quickly.
Lower temperatures: Magnesium chloride
3. Which Ice Melt Is Less Expensive?
When it comes to cost, sodium chloride is the clear winner. Because rock salt is mined in solid form and requires minimal processing, it’s cheaper to produce and distribute, making it the most cost-effective option for large-scale ice removal, like municipal roads, parking lots, and industrial properties.
Magnesium chloride, on the other hand, occurs naturally in liquid brine deposits. Extracting and drying it adds production time and cost, which makes it more expensive per ton. However, its greater efficiency at lower temperatures often means you need less product by volume, offsetting some of the higher upfront cost.
More affordable: Sodium chloride
Stay Ahead of Winter with Ninja De-Icer
Don’t wait until the first storm hits to take action. Keep your property safe with high-performance de-icing products designed for fast ice removal and long-lasting protection.
Get a Quote4. Which De-Icing Product Is Less Corrosive?
Corrosion is one of the main drawbacks of using traditional rock salt. Sodium chloride (rock salt), while effective, is highly corrosive to metal, concrete, and pavement surfaces. Over time, it can weaken rebar, rust vehicles, and deteriorate infrastructure — especially when it’s used in large quantities or over multiple winters. Sodium chloride can also harm vegetation and nearby soil as chloride runoff seeps into the environment.
Magnesium chloride, by comparison, is less corrosive and safer for metal structures and vehicles, especially when it’s formulated with a corrosion inhibitor. Its chemical composition releases moisture more gradually, minimizing impact on surrounding plants. For facilities that rely on heavy equipment or metal fixtures, magnesium chloride is a smarter, more sustainable choice.
Less corrosive: Magnesium chloride
5. Rock Salt vs. Magnesium Chloride by Pet-Friendliness
Pet safety is paramount for many families. Magnesium chloride is generally the better option for pets, as it’s less irritating to paws, less toxic if ingested in small amounts, and dissolves faster, which minimizes residue on walkways. Many magnesium chloride ice melts are even marketed as pet-friendly, making them a practical choice for residential complexes, parks, and pet-care facilities.
Rock salt (sodium chloride), however, can be harsh on animals’ paws—causing dryness, cracking, and burning sensations. If tracked indoors or ingested, it can lead to dehydration or stomach irritation. For properties where pets are frequent visitors, we recommend choosing a low-corrosion, pet-safe ice melt and rinsing treated areas regularly.
Less irritating: Magnesium chloride
Which Ice Melt Is Right for You?
There’s no right or wrong answer. Choosing between magnesium chloride and sodium chloride ultimately depends on your winter conditions, surface types, and maintenance goals. If you need reliable performance in extreme cold with less corrosion and lower environmental impact, magnesium chloride is your best bet. For milder climates or large-scale applications where cost-efficiency matters most, rock salt (sodium chloride) remains a dependable and budget-friendly solution.
At Ninja De-Icer, we supply both magnesium chloride and sodium chloride ice melts, along with blended de-icing products tailored to your property’s needs. With over 25 years of industry experience, our team can help you choose the right ice removal solution for your surfaces, temperatures, and traffic levels so you can keep your lots, sidewalks, and entryways safe throughout the winter.
Get a quote today and prepare your property for a safer, ice-free winter with Ninja De-Icer.
Related Posts
Is There an Ice Melt Safe for Concrete?
Looking for concrete-safe ice melt? Read this and discover the best ice melt for concrete and how to use it without causing any damage to concrete.
How Much Ice Melt to Use: Best Practices for Winter
Learn the best practices for ice melt application, when to apply ice melt, how to spread it evenly, how often to reapply, and the best time to buy.
What Is the Best Time to Buy Rock Salt?
Learn when to buy rock salt for the best price, quality, and delivery. Avoid costly delays and 2025 shortages and keep your property safe all winter.